Book review – The Dark Side of the Hive: The Evolution of the Imperfect Honeybee

The honey bee has a very positive reputation: a clever, industrious insect that organises itself in remarkably collaborative societies. But bee researchers Robin Moritz and Robin Crewe want to balance this picture. Yes, bee colonies are a marvel, but once you stop focusing on the level of the colony, all sorts of imperfections become apparent: cheating, robberies, regicide, euthanasia, evolutionary maladaptations, illogical reproductive strategies, etc. Welcome to the dark side of the hive.

The Dark Side of the Hive

The Dark Side of the Hive: The Evolution of the Imperfect Honeybee“, written by Robin Moritz and Robin Crewe, published by Oxford University Press in November 2018 (hardback, 186 pages)

The authors make it clear from the start that their book is less controversial than you might think, nor are they suggesting that previous work needs revising or reconsidering. They make a point of writing how excellent existing research is in their opinion, mentioning books such as The Biology of the Honey BeeBees as Superorganisms: An Evolutionary Reality, The Spirit of the Hive: The Mechanisms of Social Evolution, and especially the work of Thomas Seeley (Honeybee Ecology: A Study of Adaptation in Social Life, The Wisdom of the Hive: The Social Physiology of Honey Bee Colonies, and Honeybee Democracy). However. Going by these books alone you might get a rosy picture of honey bees and think of colonies as harmonious and perfect cooperatives. So, Moritz & Crewe want to enrich our understanding of the honey bee by, well, enlightening us on their darker side.

The Dark Side of the Hive internal 1With that carefully formulated mission statement, the authors present a relatively short book, spreading eleven chapters over 158 pages. The first few of these set the stage a bit, providing background on honey bee evolution, diet and the production and function of honey, and the use of smell (olfactory cues) and volatile chemicals in communication. There is little that the authors can pick on in these topics, and even a purported oddity in the type of pheromones used in olfaction is easily explained.

It is once we get to sex and reproduction that things get interesting and, well, odd. Take the queen*. As opposed to many other social insects, there is only one queen – no spares allowed. As soon as the young queen hatches she commits regicide, killing any other developing queens. The evolutionarily remarkable thing is that she does this *before* mating (queens of an African subspecies at least wait until *after* matings have been secured). This is a risky strategy, especially because she leaves the safety of the hive to go on her once-in-a-lifetime mating flight. What is that all about? The queens of certain stingless bees at least are sensible enough to have sex on their doorstep. Many other oddities are covered and Moritz & Crewe also delve into more theoretical aspects such as inclusive fitness theory. Honey bees are terrible poster children for this, as the queen mates with tens of males, making for a worker brood with low relatedness.

“Moritz & Crewe want to enrich our understanding of the honey bee by, well, enlightening us on the darker side.”

Beyond her majesty, the rest of the swarm can be equally inefficient and cruel. Female workers routinely euthanise sick developing brood, whereas diseased adults are either evicted or simply dismembered on the spot. Some nest parasites, on the other hand, are locked up in little wax prisons and fed. Why? Possibly they exploit some weakness in the bees’ communication system, but stingless bees simply kill such parasites by smothering them in resin, wax, and mud. And those hexagonal cells? Generations of scholars have pondered how workers tackle this geometrical challenge until people pointed out that they don’t. Freshly constructed cells are round(ish) in shape and it is the physical properties of the settling wax that results in hexagonal cells.

The Dark Side of the Hive internal 2Males, known as drones, contribute nothing more than their genetic payload in an act that literally sees them pump all their hemolymph (the insect equivalent of blood) into their endophallus, rupturing it in the process, after which they drop dead. (This is the point at which half the audience grimaces.) And even that wonderful waggle dance (see The Dancing Bees: Karl Von Frisch and the Discovery of the Honeybee Language) is not entirely error-free – the authors describe a case of workers collecting inedible seed kernels from a bird feeder (see the book’s cover), suggesting there is little feedback about food quality coming back from the hive.

These are but some of the biological idiosyncrasies that Moritz & Crewe highlight. Despite these imperfections, honey bees are an evolutionary success story. A recurring theme is that many oddities can be explained by evolution having to make do with whatever (developmental) material is at hand. Another theme, as also recently argued by Daniel S. Milo, is that evolution in biological systems is about finding feasible rather than optimal solutions (see my review of Good Enough: The Tolerance for Mediocrity in Nature and Society).

“A recurring theme is that many oddities can be explained by evolution having to make do with whatever (developmental) material is at hand.”

Beyond the biology, the authors are not afraid to highlight the dark side of apiculture (i.e. beekeeping). Apiaries form unnatural concentrations of beehives, making disease transmission easier, and commercial migratory beekeeping for crop pollination worsens this (the same California almond groves that made an appearance in Buzz: The Nature and Necessity of Bees are discussed here). Particularly revealing has been the response to the Varroa destructor mite. There is research showing that colonies can evolve natural resistance if given the time (though many colonies did not survive in these experiments). Instead, beekeepers try to salvage an already fraught situation by reaching for pesticides. Seeley’s latest book, The Lives of Bees: The Untold Story of the Honey Bee in the Wild, similarly advocates that beekeepers stop trying to fight natural selection and adopt a more Darwinian approach.

The Dark Side of the Hive internal 3The Dark Side of the Hive gets technical in places and despite the presence of helpful explanatory boxes, some jargon is not clearly defined (e.g. queenright colonies, physogastric queens). Usually, you can figure it out from the context, but a short glossary would have been helpful. The book furthermore contains quite a few illustrations where photos have been redrawn using an interlacing effect (remember the horizontal scan lines on old TV sets?). Since many of these images are already small and in greyscale, much detail is lost and sometimes I could not tell what I was looking at, so I was not terribly convinced by this stylistic choice.

Those quibbles notwithstanding, The Dark Side of the Hive offers a fascinating look at this well-studied insect. For entomologists and beekeepers, this is a must-read, but anyone with an interest in (social) insects or evolutionary biology can safely pick this up. Moritz & Crewe succeed admirably in their goal: to enrich our understanding of honey bees without overturning the existing body of research or taking away from the marvellous creatures that they are. In the process, they throw up plenty of interesting questions for future research.

* I assume most people are familiar with the fact that honey bees have a caste system with male drones, sterile female workers, and one queen who continuously lays eggs.

Disclosure: The publisher provided a review copy of this book. The opinion expressed here is my own, however.

You can support this blog using below affiliate links, as an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases:

The Dark Side of the Hive hardback or ebook

Other recommended books mentioned in this review:






Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.